A Pitch That Started with Promise
What began as one of the most warmly received pitches on Shark Tank India Season 5 ended in visible frustration. Pista Barfi, founded by Tanay Agrawal and Harshit Agrawal, entered the Tank with a product that immediately resonated with the panel.
The brand positioned itself as a modern reinterpretation of traditional Indian mithai. It focused on portability, portion control, and contemporary packaging. The Sharks appreciated how the product addressed a long-standing consumer pain point. Indian sweets taste great, but they often feel inconvenient for modern lifestyles.
Early Praise from the Sharks
The initial response was overwhelmingly positive. Vineeta Singh described Pista Barfi as the “brandification of halwai ki dukaan,” capturing its balance between tradition and modernity.
The Sharks praised both taste and presentation. They acknowledged that the founders had solved a structural problem in the category by making mithai easier to carry, store, and consume. Anupam Mittal echoed this sentiment, calling out the innovation and form factor as strong foundations.
At this stage, the pitch appeared well on track.
The Conversation Shifts to Execution
The tone changed when the discussion moved beyond the product to business execution and growth strategy. Varun Alagh pushed the founders to think distribution-first and advised them to explore quick commerce.
He pointed out that for a daily-consumption food brand or cloud kitchen model, quick commerce platforms represent where consumers actively search for food. The suggestion reframed the opportunity from niche gifting to everyday relevance.
Founder Commitment Raises Red Flags
The pitch took a decisive turn when it emerged that Harshit Agrawal was not working full-time on the business. He stated that he was unwilling to leave his production career.
This disclosure immediately raised concerns. Varun Alagh chose to step out, citing lack of founder commitment as a deal-breaker. For him, the absence of full-time involvement signaled execution risk, regardless of product quality.
Momentum Matters More Than Taste
Kunal Bahl reinforced the concern. He reminded the founders that strong products alone do not build enduring companies. Growth, he said, depends on momentum and intensity from founders who are willing to absorb the pain of scaling.
His point was clear. Investors back people before they back products. Without full commitment, even the most promising ideas stall.
Anupam Mittal’s Breaking Point
The pitch ended on a tense note. Anupam Mittal expressed his disappointment openly and without dilution.
“I’m extremely disappointed,” he said, adding that the founders were failing to recognise the scale of the opportunity in front of them. He warned that this was not how great businesses are built and that they were overlooking a potential gold mine.
His reaction reflected frustration not with the product, but with the mindset behind it.
No Deal Despite Strong Fundamentals
Pista Barfi exited the Tank without securing an investment. This outcome came despite steady revenue growth, healthy margins, and strong brand appeal.
The episode delivered a familiar Shark Tank lesson. Innovation can open doors, but founder conviction determines whether they stay open. In the Tank, the seriousness of intent matters as much as taste on the plate.
Photo: ISN
Follow us on Instagram and stay updated with our current news
